Logo

Omar Statement Amid Iran Conflict Sparks Questions About ‘Treason’

Omar Statement Amid Iran Conflict Sparks Questions About ‘Treason’

Rep. Ilhan Omar, D Minn., is facing backlash after falsely claiming the United States deliberately targets Muslim nations during Ramadan. “Iraq was attacked by the US during Ramadan and it is sickening to know that the US is again going to attack Iran during Ramadan,” Omar wrote on X as tensions escalated ahead of a U.S. strike on Iran.

“The US apparently loves to strike Muslim countries during Ramadan and I am convinced it isn’t what these countries have done to violate international law but about who they worship,” she added.

Critics argue that such rhetoric, delivered during an active military standoff, risks giving adversaries propaganda they can weaponize.

Under the Constitution, treason is narrowly defined as levying war against the United States or adhering to its enemies, giving them aid and comfort. Legal scholars have long noted that the “aid and comfort” standard requires intent and tangible support, not merely controversial speech.

Still, opponents contend that accusing the United States of religiously motivated warfare while American forces face potential retaliation could be construed as echoing hostile narratives advanced by the Iranian regime.

They argue that when a sitting member of Congress frames U.S. military action as anti-Muslim aggression, it may embolden adversaries and undermine American diplomatic leverage.

Supporters of Omar counter that political speech, even sharp criticism of U.S. foreign policy, is protected under the First Amendment. They note that courts have historically set an extraordinarily high bar for proving treason, requiring overt acts and clear evidence of intentional alignment with an enemy power.

The debate underscores the tension between protected political expression and rhetoric that critics say risks crossing into dangerous territory during moments of international crisis.

Omar was also hit with a community note on X after making the claim that the United States targets Muslim nations during Ramadan.

 

Users quickly pointed out that the U.S. invasion of Iraq under President George W. Bush began March 20, 2003, seven months before Ramadan that year.

They also noted that President George H.W. Bush launched Operation Desert Storm on Jan. 17, 1991, roughly two months before Ramadan began that year, a campaign that ultimately liberated Kuwait.

“Claiming America ‘chooses Ramadan to attack Muslims’ is not advocacy, it is a deliberate lie meant to inflame anger and divide Americans,” said Dalia al-Aqidi, a Muslim Iraqi-American running against Omar for her House seat.

The episode is not the first time the Minnesota Democrat and ‘Squad’ member has faced scrutiny over factual claims.

Earlier this year, when pressed on Capitol Hill about a $9 billion social services fraud case in her district, Omar disputed the premise and challenged a reporter’s understanding of the figures.

“Your brain has told you that it is possible for half of the resources for our public service to have disappeared? Listen to yourself,” she said.

Last fall, responding on TikTok to questions about her family’s reported wealth, Omar said critics misread her financial disclosure forms and argued that a listed valuation reflected her husband’s company’s total worth rather than his ownership stake.

“Learn to read before you post misleading s–t,” she said.

Omar’s latest comments came as the United States Department of State advised U.S. Embassy personnel in Israel to depart the region Friday “while commercial flights are available,” signaling potential airspace closures amid anticipated strikes or retaliatory action from Iran.

Tomahawk Strike Shocks the World
U.S. Tomahawk Hit Naval Base Beside Iranian School, Video Shows The evidence contradicts President Trump’s claim that Iran was responsible for a strike at the school that killed 175 people, most of them children. A newly released video adds to the evidence that an American missile likely hit an Iranian elementary school where 175 people, many of them children, were reported killed. The video, uploaded on Sunday by Iran’s semiofficial Mehr News Agency and verified by The New York Times, shows a Tomahawk cruise missile striking a naval base beside the school in the town of Minab on Feb. 28. The U.S. military is the only force involved in the conflict that uses Tomahawk missiles. A body of evidence assembled by The Times — including satellite imagery, social media posts and other verified videos — indicates that the Shajarah Tayyebeh elementary school building was severely damaged by a precision strike that occurred at the same time as attacks on the naval base. The base is operated by the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps. Asked by a reporter from The Times on Saturday if the United States had bombed the school, President Trump said: “No. In my opinion and based on what I’ve seen, that was done by Iran.” He said, “They’re very inaccurate, as you know, with their munitions.” Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, who was standing beside Mr. Trump, said the Pentagon was investigating, “but the only side that targets civilians is Iran.” The video of the strike, which was first reported by the research collective Bellingcat, was independently verified by The Times. We compared features visible in the footage to new satellite imagery captured days after the strikes in Minab. The video was filmed from a construction site opposite the base and shows a worn, dirt path across a grassy area and piles of debris also evident in recent satellite imagery, bolstering its credibility. The video also comports with other verified videos taken in the immediate aftermath of the strikes. A Times analysis of the video shows the missile striking a building described as a medical clinic in the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps base. Plumes of smoke and debris shoot out of the building after it is hit as the distant screams of onlookers are heard. As the camera pans to the right, large plumes of dust and smoke are already billowing from the area around the elementary school, suggesting that it had been struck shortly before the strike on the naval base. This is supported by a timeline of the strikes assembled by The Times that shows the school was hit around the same time as the base. Several other buildings inside the naval base were also hit by precision strikes in the attack, an analysis of satellite imagery showed. Determining precisely what happened has been impeded by the lack of visible weapons fragments and the inability of outside reporters to reach the scene. The Times has identified the weapon seen in the new video as a Tomahawk cruise missile, a weapon that neither the Israeli military nor the Iranian military has. Dozens of Tomahawks have been launched by U.S. Navy warships into Iran since Feb. 28, when the U.S.-Israeli attack on Iran began.U.S. Central Command said a video it released of several Tomahawks being launched from Navy ships was filmed on Feb. 28, the day the Iranian base and school were hit. The Defense Department describes Tomahawks as “long-range, highly accurate” guided missiles that can fly about 1,000 miles. They are programmed with a specific flight plan before launch, and the missiles steer themselves to their targets.Each Tomahawk is about 20 feet long and has a wingspan of eight and a half feet, according to the Navy. The most commonly used Tomahawks have warheads that contain the explosive power of about 300 pounds of TNT. Trevor Ball, a former U.S. Army explosive ordnance disposal technician who works with Bellingcat, also identified the missile in the video as a Tomahawk, as did another weapons expert, Chris Cobb-Smith, director of Chiron Resources, a security and logistics agency. Gen. Dan Caine, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said at a news conference on Wednesday that U.S. forces were carrying out strikes in southern Iran at the time the naval base and school were hit. A map he presented showed that an area including Minab, which is near the Strait of Hormuz, had been targeted by strikes in the first 100 hours of the operation, although it did not explicitly identify the town. “Along the southern axis, the U.S.S. Abraham Lincoln strike group has continued to provide pressure from the sea along the southeastern side of the coast and has been attriting naval capability all along the strait,” the general said. It is not the only time that General Caine has acknowledged the role Tomahawk missiles played in the early hours of the war. “The first shooters at sea were Tomahawks unleashed by the United States Navy,” he said in a briefing to reporters at the Pentagon on March 2, as the Navy “began to conduct strikes across the southern flank in Iran.” In June, a Navy submarine launched more than two dozen Tomahawks at a nuclear facility in Isfahan, Iran, as part of the 12-day war.